No products in the cart.
How to Sell Your Coins for Top Dollar
Selling your coin collection can feel overwhelming—especially if you’re unsure who to trust. Many collectors leave their coins sitting in a closet for years because they’re intimidated by the process. At Safe Haven Exchange, we want to make it simple, transparent, and rewarding. Below is our step-by-step guide to help you get the most for your coins.
Step 1: Identify the Type of Collection You Have
Not all collections are created equal. Understanding your collection will help determine its value and the level of interest from coin experts. Most collections fall into these categories
Key takeaway: Rare and attractive coins sell quickly and for strong premiums. Common or damaged coins are harder to sell and may fetch less.
- True Collector Coin Collection – Carefully assembled through auctions or dealers, with time, money, and expertise invested.
- Coin Assemblage or Hoard – A mix gathered over time, often containing 90% silver coins or circulated coins from the 1800s and newer.
- Mint Products Collection – Proof sets, mint sets, and bullion purchased directly from the U.S. Mint (typically from the 1960s and newer).
- Late Night TV Collection – Items sold through TV promotions, such as Franklin Mint products or coins with certificates of authenticity.
Step 2: Understand Dealer Spreads & Profit Margins
Different dealers operate in different markets. A small local shop may pay $4 for a coin they can sell for $5, while a national dealer with serious buyers may pay $3,750 for a coin worth $4,000 because they have the clients ready to buy.
What this means for you:
- Don’t rely on book prices or eBay listings alone.
- Offers vary based on a dealer’s network, expertise, and ability to sell.
- The best offer often comes from the dealer best positioned to resell your collection—not necessarily the first or lowest bidder.
Key takeaway: Rare and attractive coins sell quickly and for strong premiums. Common or damaged coins are harder to sell and may fetch less.
Step 3: Create a Detailed Inventory
An organized inventory shows coin experts that you know what you have—and helps you get stronger offers.
- List coins by year, mintmark, denomination, and condition in Word or Excel.
- Avoid sending only group photos or hundreds of scattered images.
- A clear list allows us to quickly spot rare or high-value coins.
Tip: A detailed inventory signals professionalism and prevents lowball offers.
Step 4: Set Realistic Expectations
It’s easy to get misled by stories, old receipts, or high online listings.
- A coin your relative bought for $35 in the 1980s may not be worth much more today.
- Just because a coin is listed on eBay for $5,000 doesn’t mean it sells for that.
- Real value comes from recent sales and auction records.
At Safe Haven Exchange, we base our offers on real market data—not inflated book prices.
Step 5: Get Multiple Opinions—But Stay Fair
For high-value collections (e.g., $50,000+), always get two or three quotes. Professional dealers expect this.
- You won’t offend anyone by comparing offers.
- Avoid exaggerating or misrepresenting what other buyers offered.
- A fair, transparent approach will result in stronger offers.
Step 6: Choose the Right Coin Experts
When you’re ready to sell, present your collection with professionalism:
“Here is the inventory of my coin collection. I can provide additional details and photos upon request. I’m seeking a couple of offers and would like to get a price from your company.”
This approach always earns respect—and better offers.
At Safe Haven Exchange, we pride ourselves on:
- Trusted Expertise: Our specialists provide honest appraisals backed by years of experience.
- Fair Market Value: Offers are based on real-time pricing, collector demand, and market conditions.
- Fast & Secure Payments: Choose wire transfers, checks, or account credit—with every transaction fully insured.
- A Seamless Process: We guide you step-by-step for a stress-free selling experience.
Ready to Sell Your Collection?
Whether you’re selling a single coin or a multi-million-dollar estate, Safe Haven Exchange is here to maximize your return while making the process smooth and secure.
Main
Shop
Education
Others
Copyright 2025 Safe Haven Exchange
Website Designed by 
| Developed & Maintained by 
| Developed & Maintained by